WE'VE MOVED! IsraPundit has relocated to Click here to go there now.
News and views on Israel, Zionism and the war on terrorism.

February 12, 2003


Edward Said upended, at last, according to article posted by Martin Kramer
Here is interesting news about Edward Said, Columbia University's celebrity professor of English literature, Palestine, Islam, and what-have-you. Said has a long-standing connection to King's College, Cambridge. He has the status of a member, and has been an occasional visitor there, most recently this past fall. The College is a redoubt of the left. Its provost, Patrick Bateson, signed a letter to The Guardian last April, calling for an academic moratorium on contacts with Israel. That unleashed a tidal wave of publicity and criticism that shook the Provost's Lodge and the College.

So it was particularly unwise for Edward Said's friends to choose this moment to nominate their hero for an honorary fellowship of the College. The inner deliberations of the College congregation are not public, but The Guardian picked up enough gossip to make a story. Details are murky, but the bottom line is that two fellows who had criticized Bateson also spoke persuasively against Said's nomination, and apparently succeeded in nixing it.

It's not often that Edward Said gets turned down for honors these days, and I find it refreshing. No one has done more than Said to confuse scholarship and advocacy, and it frankly looks pathetic when his partisans rush to his defense by declaiming his scholarly virtues. Edward Said is a package deal. At King's College there are people who rightly understood that honoring Said would be interpreted as honoring his politics. I don't know exactly how it happened, or what the arguments were, but King's College has kept its honor.

Of course, in America it's another story. Berkeley is about to enjoy a visit by Said, hosted by its (federally-funded) Center for Middle Eastern Studies, and paid for in part by the Chancellor's fund. The Daily Californian carries a strange quote from the vice-chair of the Center: "We're inviting him in his capacity as a university professor. Edward Said is an important advocate of Palestinians but also a professor of English." You would think that Said had been invited to lecture on Austen or Conrad. But I doubt there will be much literature in a lecture with this title: "The U.S., the Islamic World and the Question of Palestine." My prediction: the lecture's only relationship to English will be that it is delivered in English. You can judge for yourself from the webcast, which is supposed to become available on February 20. [more]