WE'VE MOVED! IsraPundit has relocated to Click here to go there now.
News and views on Israel, Zionism and the war on terrorism.

October 30, 2002

From UN Watch

UN Watch is an excellent organization. This is from their weekly report, and I recommend e-mailing it around to anyone interested in Israel issues:

Wednesday, 30 October 2002
Issue 89

UN Special Rapporteurs are mandated to conduct fact-finding missions and
bring to the United Nations informed and independent judgments. On November
5, Mr. John Dugard, the UN's Special Rapporteur for issues of human rights
in the West Bank and Gaza, will present to the UN General Assembly a report
that omits crucial and obvious facts and contradicts UN reporting policy on

One day before the first anniversary of the September 11 attacks, the United
Nations' Policy Working Group on the United Nations and Terrorism issued a
report that included the following statement: "In its public pronouncements,
the United Nations should project a clear and principled message,
underscoring the unacceptability of terrorism ... These messages must be
targeted to key audiences -- particularly to achieve a greater impact in
dissuading would-be supporters of terrorist acts."

An advance copy of Mr. Dugard's report shows utter disregard for UN policy
as well as common sense. He demonstrates such willful ignorance of the
threat and motivation of Palestinian terrorist organizations that the report
could only have been written in bad faith.

Mr. Dugard's most recent trip to Israel and the West Bank took place August
25-30. Four days before he arrived, two car bombs were intercepted by
Israeli soldiers near Jenin. This security operation was reported in The
Jerusalem Post, a leading English-language Israeli newspaper. Four days
after Mr. Dugard left, a car bomb containing 600 kg of explosives was
stopped at a roadblock. This incident was reported by the BBC. Ignoring
these incidents, Mr. Dugard describes Israeli closures as "so
disproportionate, so remote from the interests of security, that one is led
to ask whether they are not in part designed to punish, humiliate, and
subjugate the Palestinian people." As for the roadblocks themselves, he
fails to make even one mention of the fact that they have thwarted dozens of
suicide bombings this year, though media reports to substantiate these facts
are easily accessible in English for anyone inclined to look. Instead Mr.
Dugard offers only three sentences, written more in the style of an aspiring
novelist than a fact-finder: "A group of young soldiers, with the arrogance
of adolescence or its immediate aftermath, in dusty uniforms with ominous
rifles over their shoulders, entrusted with arbitrary power over the
movement of the people of Palestine. Long lines of vehicles or people
presenting papers to soldiers behind concrete blocks, all aware that their
movement is completely in the hands of these young foreign soldiers. The
arrogance of the occupier and the humiliation of the occupied." That's all.

To explain and excuse Palestinian terror, Mr. Dugard postulates that it is
"the hopelessness of despair which leads inexorably to suicide bombings."
While the admittedly miserable situation of the Palestinians may generate
more recruits for Islamic terror organizations, clearly the ideology of
jihad is the motive of Hamas and Islamic Jihad. Again Mr. Dugard ignores
readily available documents and statements of Hamas and Islamic Jihad, the
main perpetrators of suicide bombings. Easily found on terrorism-related web
sites, the English translation of the Hamas Charter states: "To face the
usurpation of Palestine by Jews, we have no escape from raising the banner
of Jihad." Mr. Dugard also managed to overlook a Hamas statement, after the
Hebrew University bombing on August 1, that Jews should leave Israel and
"return to where they came from." And this statement was reported in the
English-language press. Only gross incompetence or willful ignorance can
explain Mr. Dugard's omission of these facts.

Mr. Dugard's report is a disgrace to the institution of UN Special
Rapporteurs. In addition, his "see no evil" approach to Palestinian terror
contradicts each of the UN Policy Working Group's criteria for UN statements
on terror: clarity, principle, unacceptability of terrorism, and dissuasion.
Mr. Dugard should resign without delay.